The Most Debated Movie Endings of All Time
The closing scenes that broke the internet
There’s still that one guy at a party, drunk at 12am, arguing about the spinning top from the 2010 Inception. Is Christopher Nolan a genius? Yes. Did Leonardo DiCaprio get home to his children? We don’t know. He believes he didn’t (be he also loves conspiracy theories and believes the NASA faked the moon landing, so let’s leave that there.)
Many movies wrap up a beautiful ending and send us home. We feel tidy and maybe reach that catharsis we intended to. But then there are movies that literally leave us spiralling on Google after looking for answers at 3 a.m. Yes Linda, I know I have work tomorrow. No, I won’t stop reading about Fight Club.
You may also like
Most Debated Movie Endings
Here are some of the best movie endings that still get us arguing.
Inception (2010)
The honest answer is that the debate about whether Cobb is dreaming was always a little beside the point. Nolan said as much: what matters is that Cobb sets the top spinning and walks away without watching it fall. That's the film. A man so wrecked by grief that he built entire architectures of the mind to keep his dead wife alive — and he finally, just, lets go. Whether he's in a dream or not is almost administrative at that point. But people don't want to let it go, because the film taught them not to trust anything. It earned that paranoia, frame by frame, and then asked you to relax at the end. Of course we can't!
The Shining (1980)
The photograph at the end of Kubrick's The Shining is still the most devastating image in horror. Jack Torrance — frozen in a hedge maze, beaten by a place that was never going to let him leave anyway — turns up in a hotel party photo dated July 4th, 1921. Smiling.
You may also like
Kubrick told a French critic the image "suggests the reincarnation of Jack." That's the most anyone ever got out of him, and it's not much. What it implies is worse than any explanation: that the Overlook didn't corrupt Jack. He was always going to end up there, in that photograph, at that party, grinning in black and white.
Fight Club (1999)
The culture has done a full lap on Fight Club and is still running. When it came out in 1999, a certain kind of man watched it and heard a manifesto. Fincher and Palahniuk were watching those men and making notes. The film was never the thing those men thought it was — it's a portrait of a person so alienated from himself that he had to invent a more interesting one, and then couldn't control what he'd made.
The ending should've settled it: Tyler Durden is a symptom, not a solution. You can't blow up your way to an identity. The narrator destroys his alter ego and still ends up holding hands with a woman while the skyline falls, which is not exactly a stable foundation for a new life.
2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)
You could spend a lifetime on the last twenty minutes of 2001 and not crack it, and Kubrick knew that when he made it. He and Clarke built the ambiguity in deliberately. The stargate. The room. The old man eating alone. The monolith. The foetus, floating in orbit, looking down at Earth with enormous eyes. The Star Child.
You may also like
The film came out in 1968, the year everything broke open. It landed on audiences already untethered and gave them an ending that felt overwhelming and blinding. Fifty years on, it still doesn't make sense.
Life of Pi (2012)
Ang Lee gives you two stories and asks which one you believe. The first has a tiger, a carnivorous island, a boy surviving the unsurvivable through wonder and instinct and faith. The second has no animals — only people, and what people do to each other when there's nothing left, and a boy who survived it by turning it into something he could live with.
Pi asks the journalist — asks us — which story we prefer. The journalist picks the tiger. "And so it goes with God," Pi says.
Lost in Translation (2003)
Nobody heard what Bob whispered! Coppola won't say. And none of that matters, because the scene works precisely because we're not in it.
The whole film is about two people who found each other in the gap between who they were and who they were supposed to be — wrong cities, wrong marriages, wrong decades. The whisper is the last thing that belongs only to them.
Us (2019)
Peele ends Us with Adelaide driving away, her son having watched her jaw unhinge in the animal way that only the Tethered do. He knows what she is. She knows he knows. The car keeps moving.
Cut to the Tethered, still alive, holding hands across the country in a dark mirror of Hands Across America. Peele has said he wanted the Tethered to be available to multiple interpretations: the underclass, the shadow self, the history America keeps underground and pretends isn't there. All of it works.